Witches Brew Coffee House Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing the menu at Witches Brew Coffee House in West Hempstead, NY. This cafe offers a unique blend of Italian and American cuisine, with a focus on vegan and vegetarian options. The ambiance is charming and inviting, perfect for a cozy date night or casual hangout with friends. Customers rave about the impeccable food quality and warm service, praising dishes like the pesto gnocchi and delicious teas. The staff is attentive and friendly, adding to the relaxed and comfortable atmosphere. While some wait times can be lengthy, the experience is worth it for the top-quality, house-made dishes. With options for outdoor seating, catering, and even accepting cryptocurrency, Witches Brew Coffee House is a standout gem in Long Island's dining scene.

Appetizers

Goat Cheese Crostini

Warm crostini with black cherry marmalade, crumbled goat cheese & a sweet reduction sauce.

$9.25

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

Homemade baked spinach & artichoke dip served with tortilla chips

$12.25

Bruschetta

Fresh tomato, red onion, basil,olive oil & balsamic vinegar on a garlic crostini topped with grated parmesan.

$11.50

Nachos

Nachos with black beans, olives, jalapeno & cheese topped with pico de gallo & guacamole crema

$9.95

Mac & Cheese

Our famous baked mac & cheese made with types of cheese.

$9.95

Hummus & Pita (V)

House made organic hummus served with a warm pita.

$8.50

Vegetable Spring Roll (V)

vegetable spring rolls served with sweet chili sauce

$7.25

Steamed Vegetable Dumplings (V)

Steamed vegetable dumpling served with sweet chili & home made dumpling sauce.

$9.00

Charred Hoisin Brussel Sprouts Served With Side Of Rice (V)

$7.95

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce, grated parmesan cheese & croutons in a house made caesar dressing

$9.95

Greek Salad

Romaine lettuce, cucumber, grape tomato, peppers, red onion, olives & feta cheese dressed in a red wine vinaigrette.

$9.95

Beet Salad

Sliced roasted beets, hearts of palm, mango, dried cranberry, fresh spinach & arugula tossed in a orange vinaigrette topped with goat cheese.

$9.95

Chickpea Salad (V)

Organic chickpeas, arugula, diced tomato, cucumber, peppers, red onion & fresh parsley tossed with lemon juice & olive oil.

$9.95

Salad

Main Course

Pesto Gnocchi Or Tomato Gnocchi

Homemade creamy pesto or organic tomato sauce & shredded parmesan cheese.

$13.95

Butternut Squash & Sage, Butter Gnocchi. (V)

Sauteed roasted butter nut squash with sage butter & gnocchi topped with toasted pumpkin seeds.

$13.95

Trofie Alfredo & Mushroom

Cortecce pasta in a creamy alfredo mushroom sauce & shredded parmesan cheese.

$13.95

Quesadilla

Bean and cheese quesadilla served with pico de gallo and sour cream.

$11.25

Middle Eastern Platter (V)

Small plates of hummus, tabouli salad, four falafel balls and olives served with warm pitas.

$14.95

Coconut Curry (V)(Gfd)

Spicy thai red curry with tofu, mixed vegetables & rice noodles topped with fresh shredded cabbage & cilantro.

$13.95

Pad Thai (V)

Sauteed vegetables, tofu & rice noodles tossed in a wok with our special tamarind sauce & topped with crushed peanuts.

$13.95

Kale & Tofu Stir Fry (V) (Gf)

Organic kale organic tofu & organic jasmine rice stir fried together with organic tamari sauce ginger & garlic.

$15.95

Mapo Tofu (V)

A spicy sichuan dish made with organic silken tofu & sichuan peppers served with organic jasmine rice.

$13.95

Jamaican Jerk Tofu Steak (V)

Organic tofu with a spicy jerk sauce served with organic jasmine rice, organic sauteed kale & chickpeas.

$13.95

Vegetable Of The Day (V)

$6.95

French Fries (V)

$6.95

Sweet Chili Potato Squares (V)

$6.95

Sauteed Corn & Herbs

$6.95

Sides

Sandwiches

Falafel Sandwich(V)

Homemade falafel with hummus,fresh chopped salad & tahini suace tahani sauce comes with potato salad or garden salad

$11.95

Veggeie Burger

House made veggie burger topped with cheddar cheese,tomato,lettuce,onion & pickles dressed with a spicy with a spicy mayo on a ciabatta roll comes with potato salad or garden salad

$11.95

Classic Italian

Fresh mozzarella,roasted peppers,red onion,tomato,basil & argula dressed with olive oil & balsamic vinegar on a ciabatta bread,comes with potato salad or garden salad

$11.95

Is Real Lite(V)

Home made organic hummus,avocado,red onion,tomato & spinach on a whole wheat rustic bread.comes with potato salad or garden salad

$11.95

Gyro Sandwich(V)

Sauteed seitan rolled in a flat bread with red onion ,sliced tomato & shredded lettuce dressed with a mint yogurt sauce comes with potato salad or garden salad

$12.00

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Caesar salad with sliced mock chicken & parmesan cheese rolled in a warm spinach wrap.comes with potato salad or garden salad

$11.95

Grilled Cheese

Traditional white bread with choice of swiss,cheddar or fresh mozzarell.comes with potato salad or garden salad

$10.50

Tempeh Reuben (V)

Sliced tempeh coverd with hot sauerkraut on rye bread with house russian dressing.comes with potato salad or garden salad

$11.95

Philly Seitan Cheese Steak

Seitan sauteed with onions & peppers topped with melted provolone cheese.comes with potato salad or garden salad

$11.95

Organic Milk

$2.25

Organic Soy

$2.25

Organic Almond

$2.25

Coffee

Cafe Aulait

Organic Coffee With Steamed Milk

$3.50

Aloha Mocha

$6.00

Amer Midnite

Autumn

Avesrednite

Banana Cream Pie

Bat

$6.00

Black Cat

$6.00

Black + White

$6.00

Black Widow

$6.00

Black Magic

$6.00

Blue Angel

$6.00

Blue Moon

$6.00

Broomstick

$6.00

Cherrybomb

$6.00

Chocolate Velvet

$6.00

Crimsin

$6.00

Dublin

Eskimo

$6.00

Fire

$6.00

Ghost

$6.00

Gloomlifter

$6.00

Gypsy

$6.00

Halloween

$6.00

Halo

$6.00

Heaven

$6.00

Inkwell

$6.00

Espresso Drink

Bagels

Tofu Cream Cheese

$3.50

Butter Cinn & Sugar

$5.00

P.b. & Toasted Vegan Marshmallow

$6.25

Vegan Mozzerella And Peppers

$6.25

P.b. & Jelly

$5.00

Sorbet

$4.75

Tofutti

$4.75

Scoop

Others

/ Coffee

$4.00

/ Cocoa

$4.00

Hot Cocoa

$3.50

Blood Shot

Small organic coffee with espresso

$3.75

Michaels Racehorse

-oz.latte

$7.95

Allniter

Large organic coffee with double espresso

$4.75

Espresso

Organic double

$3.75

Macchiato

oz. Organic double espresso with foam

$4.00

Cappuccino

$4.50

Mochaccino

$5.25

Cafe Latte

$4.50

Americano

/ hot water with organic double espresso

$3.75

Pastry

$4.50

Brownie

$4.75

Cinn Bunn

$5.75

Smores

$4.50

Foccacia

Fresh baked bread

$5.50

King Kong

Banana chocolate marshmallow syrup

Eprechaun

Irish creme hazelnut

Midnite

Chocolate marshmallow syrup

Moon

Marshmallow syrup banana p-b

Nitemare

Caramel p-b chocolate

October

Marshmallow syrup caramel p-b

P B Jelly

Grape p-b

Pink Angel

Strawberry vanilla

Reddeath

Cherry chocolate

Revolution

Hazelnut chocolate caramel

Snowflake

Vanilla mint marshmallow syrup

Solstice

Maple & english toffee

Sorrow

Chocolate & cupcake

Southern Revolution

Praline caramel chocolate

Sugardaddy

Caramel praline

Sweetness

Caramel almond roca

The Ciash

English toffee caramel

Tyranny

Coconut chocolate caramel

Vagabond

Caramel coconut

Vamp

Raspberry chocolate

Yoodoo

French vanilla marshmallow syrup

White Angel

Coconut vanilla

Winter

Marshmallow syrup vanilla

Witch Doctor

Vanilla p-b hazelnut

Wish

Strawberry & cupcake

Zombie

Tiramisu chocolate